Bills · H.Res. 1655 · Text
Introduced in House
Confirmed from the official record
Our copy of the file on govinfo.gov, saved November 17, 2026. Fingerprint (SHA-256): 72e9751ce9033732.
[Congressional Bills 119th Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
[H. Res. 1655 Introduced in House (IH)]
<DOC>
119th CONGRESS
2d Session
H. RES. 1655
Impeaching Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Defense, for high crimes
and misdemeanors.
_______________________________________________________________________
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
November 10, 2026
Mr. Massie submitted the following resolution
November 11, 2026
By motion of the House, referred to the Committee on the Judiciary
_______________________________________________________________________
RESOLUTION
Impeaching Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Defense, for high crimes
and misdemeanors.
Resolved, That Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Defense, also
referred to as Secretary of War by the Administration, is impeached for
high crimes and misdemeanors and that the following articles of
impeachment be exhibited to the United States Senate:
Articles of impeachment exhibited by the House of Representatives
of the United States of America in the name of itself and of the people
of the United States of America, against Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary
of Defense, in maintenance and support of its impeachment against him
for high crimes and misdemeanors.
article i: waging war in contravention of the war powers resolution of
1973 section 2(c)
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct while Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his
constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--
especially with regard to the commission of war--has abused the powers
of the Department of Defense in that:
The Declare War Clause of the United States Constitution--Article
I, Section 8, Clause 11--vests in Congress the exclusive initiatory
powers of war, while the Military, Administrative, and Clemency Clause
of the United States Constitution--Article II, Section 2, Clause 1--
establishes the President as the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces
and vests in him operational control over wars lawfully authorized by
Congress. In an effort to statutorily delineate the circumstances under
which the President may introduce United States Armed Forces into
hostilities absent congressional authorization, the 93d Congress of the
United States enacted into law House Joint Resolution 542, the War
Powers Resolution of 1973 (Public Law 93-148), by overriding the veto
of President Richard Nixon.
Peter Brian Hegseth, in his capacity as Secretary of Defense, has
executed unlawful orders in contravention of Section 2(c) of the War
Powers Resolution of 1973, section 1541(c) of title 50, United States
Code.
Section 2(c) provides that ``the constitutional powers of the
President as Commander-in-Chief to introduce United States Armed Forces
into hostilities, or into situations where imminent involvement in
hostilities is clearly indicated by the circumstances, are exercised
only pursuant to (1) a declaration of war, (2) specific statutory
authorization, or (3) a national emergency created by attack upon the
United States, its territories or possessions, or its armed forces.''.
The War Powers Resolution further expressly provides that nothing
contained therein ``shall be construed as granting any authority to the
President'' to introduce United States Armed Forces into hostilities
which the President would not otherwise possess in the absence of the
Resolution. Accordingly, the reporting and termination procedures
subsequently established by the Resolution do not themselves constitute
affirmative statutory authorization to commence hostilities; rather,
the introduction of United States Armed Forces into hostilities must
rest upon one of the authorities or circumstances identified in section
2(c) in order for a conflict to be considered lawful.
With respect to United States Armed Forces being entered into
hostilities in the Islamic Republic of Iran on February 28, 2026,
Secretary Hegseth directed and caused United States Armed Forces to be
introduced into hostilities against the Islamic Republic of Iran
notwithstanding that--
(1) Congress had not declared war against the Islamic
Republic of Iran;
(2) Congress had not enacted any specific statutory
authorization for the introduction of United States Armed
Forces into hostilities against the Islamic Republic of Iran;
and
(3) no national emergency had been created by an attack by
the Islamic Republic of Iran upon the United States, its
territories or possessions, or its Armed Forces.
Furthermore, no imminent attack upon the United States, its
territories or possessions, or its Armed Forces existed, as affirmed in
the March 17, 2026, resignation letter of Joe Kent, then-Director of
the National Counterterrorism Center, in which he stated: ``I cannot in
good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran. Iran posed no imminent
threat to our nation.''.
The introduction of United States Armed Forces into hostilities
against the Islamic Republic of Iran therefore satisfied none of the
circumstances expressly identified in section 2(c) of the War Powers
Resolution and was undertaken, from its inception, without
congressional authorization or independent Article II authority,
thereby rendering both the initial introduction of United States Armed
Forces into hostilities, and all subsequent actions taken thereafter,
unlawful.
Secretary Hegseth nevertheless knowingly executed and implemented
the order to commence such hostilities, employing the powers,
personnel, weapons, and resources of the Department of Defense to
initiate military action against another sovereign nation, in violation
of section 1541(c) of title 50, United States Code.
Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of his high office through the
following means:
(1) Executing an unlawful order to commence hostilities
despite the absence of a declaration of war, specific statutory
authorization, or a national emergency created by an attack
upon the United States, its territories or possessions, or its
Armed Forces.
(2) Continuing to employ the personnel and resources of the
Department of Defense in those hostilities after their unlawful
initiation and in the continued absence of any subsequent
declaration of war or specific statutory authorization by
Congress.
Through these actions, Secretary Hegseth knowingly executed and
implemented unlawful orders to initiate war against a foreign nation
notwithstanding the absence of congressional authorization, an attack
upon the United States giving rise to the national emergency
contemplated by law, or an imminent threat requiring immediate
defensive action, thereby substituting unlawful executive action for
the constitutional and statutory judgment of Congress.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth has acted in a manner contrary to
his trust as Secretary of Defense and subversive of constitutional
government, to the great prejudice of the cause of law and justice, and
to the manifest injury of the people of the United States of America.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution if
allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
article ii: waging war in contravention of the war powers resolution of
1973 section 5(c)
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct while Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his
constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--
especially with regard to the commission of war--has abused the powers
of the Department of Defense in that:
The Declare War Clause of the United States Constitution--Article
I, Section 8, Clause 11--vests in Congress the exclusive initiatory
powers of war, while the Military, Administrative, and Clemency Clause
of the United States Constitution--Article II, Section 2, Clause 1--
establishes the President as the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces
and vests in him operational control over wars lawfully authorized by
Congress. In an effort to statutorily delineate the circumstances under
which the President may introduce United States Armed Forces into
hostilities absent congressional authorization, the 93d Congress of the
United States of America enacted into law House Joint Resolution 542,
the War Powers Resolution of 1973. (Public Law 93-148), by overriding
the veto of President Richard Nixon.
Secretary Hegseth carried out unlawful orders, and continues to do
so, in contravention of Section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution of
1973, section 1544(c) of title 50, United States Code.
Section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution of 1973 provides that
``at any time that United States Armed Forces are engaged in
hostilities outside the territory of the United States, its possessions
and territories without a declaration of war or specific statutory
authorization, such forces shall be removed by the President if the
Congress so directs by concurrent resolution.''.
With respect to United States Armed Forces being engaged in
hostilities in the Islamic Republic of Iran, pursuant to Section 5(c),
the House of Representatives and the Senate agreed, by the yeas and
nays, to a concurrent resolution directing the President to remove
United States Armed Forces from unauthorized hostilities in Iran (House
Concurrent Resolution 86 of the 119th Congress). The House agreed to
this concurrent resolution on June 3, 2026, and the Senate agreed to it
on June 23, 2026, marking the first successful passage of such a
legislative vehicle by both chambers of Congress in the history of the
United States of America.
In response, and without lawful cause or excuse, Secretary Hegseth
continued to direct United States Armed Forces into hostilities with
the Islamic Republic of Iran on June 26, 2026, and continues to do so
in violation of Section 1544(c) of Title 50, United States Code.
Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of his high office through the
following means:
(1) Directing, authorizing, and sustaining hostile United
States military actions in Iran after both Chambers of Congress
agreed to House Concurrent Resolution 86, thereby disregarding
Congress' express and lawful direction that United States Armed
Forces be removed from such hostilities.
(2) Failing and refusing to take all necessary steps within
his authority as Secretary of Defense to withdraw United States
Armed Forces from hostilities in Iran.
(3) Directing the Department of Defense to ignore the duly
agreed concurrent resolution, thereby substituting the judgment
of the Executive Branch for the constitutional and statutory
judgment of Congress and nullifying Congress' exercise of its
war powers.
Through these actions, Secretary Hegseth knowingly executed and
sustained unlawful orders that treated the Executive Branch as
possessing authority to determine when war may be commenced, how long
it may be sustained, and whether Congress' direction to terminate
hostilities must be obeyed. By implementing those orders, he
effectuated, in practice, the unilateral continuation of military
operations against Iran despite Congress' exclusive constitutional
authority to declare war and despite Congress' formal action directing
the removal of United States Armed Forces from hostilities. This abuse
of office frustrated Congress' ability to exercise its most solemn
constitutional responsibility, enabled the continuation of an unlawful
war, and ignored--and thus nullified--the fundamental safeguard
designed to prevent United States Armed Forces from being used at the
will of the Executive alone.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth has acted in a manner contrary to
his trust as Secretary of Defense and subversive of constitutional
government, to the great prejudice of the cause of law and justice, and
to the manifest injury of the people of the United States.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution if
allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
article iii: waging war in contravention of the war powers resolution
of 1973 section 5(b)
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct while Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his
constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--
especially with regard to the commission of war--has abused the powers
of the Department of Defense in that:
The Declare War Clause of the United States Constitution--Article
I, Section 8, Clause 11--vests in Congress the exclusive initiatory
powers of war, while the Military, Administrative, and Clemency Clause
of the United States Constitution--Article II, Section 2, Clause 1--
establishes the President as the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces
and vests in him operational control over wars lawfully authorized by
Congress. In an effort to statutorily delineate the circumstances under
which the President may introduce United States Armed Forces into
hostilities absent congressional authorization, the 93d Congress of the
United States enacted into law House Joint Resolution 542, the War
Powers Resolution of 1973 (Public Law 93-148), by overriding the veto
of President Richard Nixon.
Secretary Hegseth carried out unlawful orders, and continues to do
so, in contravention of section 5(b) of the War Powers Resolution of
1973, section 1544(b) of title 50, United States Code.
Section 5(b) of the War Powers Resolution of 1973 provides that,
within 60 calendar days after a report is submitted or is required to
be submitted to Congress by the President of the United States upon the
Executive introducing United States Armed Forces into hostilities or
into situations where imminent involvement in hostilities is clearly
indicated by the circumstances, whichever is earlier, the Executive
``shall terminate any use of United States Armed Forces... unless the
Congress (1) has declared war or has enacted a specific authorization
for such use of United States Armed Forces, (2) has extended by law
such 60-day period, or (3) is physically unable to meet as a result of
an armed attack upon the United States.''.
Section 5(b) further provides that, absent a formal congressional
declaration of war, specific statutory authorization for the use of
military force, or an extension of the 60-day period enacted into law
during that period, ``such 60-day period shall be extended for not more
than an additional 30 days if the President determines and certifies to
the Congress in writing that unavoidable military necessity respecting
the safety of United States Armed Forces requires the continued use of
such armed forces in the course of bringing about a prompt removal of
such forces.''.
With respect to United States Armed Forces being entered into
hostilities in the Islamic Republic of Iran, and indicating reliance on
and fealty to the War Powers Resolution of 1973 as legal justification
for entering United States Armed Forces into hostilities with Iran
without the initiatory authority of Congress, President Donald J. Trump
transmitted, on March 2, 2026, ``a letter informing Congress of action
taken consistent with the War Powers Resolution, Public Law 93-148,
pursuant to 50 U.S.C. 1543(a)(3); Public Law 93-148, Sec. 4(a); (87
Stat. 555) and 50 U.S.C. 1543(b); Public Law 93-148, Sec. 4(b); (87
Stat. 555),'' concerning hostilities that had commenced in Iran on
February 28, 2026.
In the 60-day period following said transmission, Congress did not
enact, and still has not enacted, any declaration or specific statutory
authorization for the use of United States Armed Forces in hostilities
against Iran or extend the applicable 60-day period by law, despite
remaining physically capable of meeting and carrying out its
constitutional responsibilities. Moreover, President Donald J. Trump
did not submit the written certification required to invoke the
additional 30-day withdrawal period by May 1, 2026. Even assuming the
President had validly invoked that separate and limited 30-day
extension, it would likewise have expired on June 1, 2026.
Without lawful cause or excuse, and despite the Executive's initial
observance of the reporting requirements under section 4(a) of the War
Powers Resolution, section 1543(a)(3) of title 50, United States Code,
through the President's transmission to Congress of a letter
acknowledging the commencement of the statutory timeline, Secretary
Hegseth continued to direct, authorize, and sustain the use of United
States Armed Forces in hostilities in the Islamic Republic of Iran
after the expiration of every potentially applicable statutory period.
Secretary Hegseth continued such hostilities after the 60-day period
expired on May 1, 2026, and after June 1, 2026, the date on which even
the maximum possible additional 30-day withdrawal period would have
expired, despite the absence of a declaration of war, specific
statutory authorization, or extension enacted by Congress.
Secretary Hegseth further contravened the limited purpose of any
such additional 30-day withdrawal period by directing United States
Armed Forces to continue engaging in hostilities against the Islamic
Republic of Iran in a manner calculated not to terminate the
unauthorized use of such forces and bring about their prompt removal,
but rather to continue prosecuting the war to pursue additional
military objectives not authorized by Congress, and has therefore
directed the Department of Defense in violation of section 1544(b) of
title 50, United States Code.
Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of his high office through the
following means:
(1) Directing, authorizing, and sustaining hostile United
States military actions in Iran after the expiration of the 60-
day period established under section 5(b) of the War Powers
Resolution of 1973, despite the absence of a declaration of
war, specific statutory authorization, or an extension enacted
by Congress.
(2) Continuing to direct and sustain hostilities in iran in
the pursuit of additional military objectives during and after
the expiration of any potentially applicable additional 30-day
period, notwithstanding that such 30-day period could be used
only when required by unavoidable military necessity respecting
the safety of United States Armed Forces in the course of
bringing about their prompt removal, as certified as necessary
by the President of the United States--a certification never
transmitted to Congress by President Donald J. Trump pursuant
to section 1544(b) of title 50, United States Code.
(3) Failing and refusing to take all necessary steps within
his authority as Secretary of Defense to terminate the
unauthorized use of United States Armed Forces and promptly
withdraw such forces from hostilities in the Islamic Republic
of Iran.
(4) Directing the Department of Defense to treat the
mandatory termination requirement as discretionary, thereby
substituting the judgment of the Executive Branch for the
constitutional and statutory judgment of Congress and
nullifying the express command that the unauthorized use of
United States Armed Forces ``shall'' be terminated.
Through these actions, Secretary Hegseth knowingly executed and
sustained unlawful orders that, in practice, displaced the
constitutional and statutory judgment of Congress by permitting the
Executive Branch to determine when war may be commenced, how long it
may be sustained, whether statutory deadlines governing unauthorized
hostilities must be obeyed, and whether a war may continue after the
expiration of every period permitted by law.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth has acted in a manner contrary to
his trust as Secretary of Defense and subversive of constitutional
government, to the great prejudice of the cause of law and justice, and
to the manifest injury of the people of the United States.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution if
allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
article iv: ignoring laws that minimize civilian casualties
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct as Secretary of
Defense and in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully
execute the office of Secretary of Defense and, to the best of his
ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United
States, and in violation of his constitutional duty to take care that
the laws be faithfully executed--especially during the commission of
war--Peter Brian Hegseth has abused the powers of the Department of
Defense, in that:
Using the powers of his office, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth
directed the Department of Defense in a manner that resulted in the
death or injury of more than 200 civilians at the Shajarah Tayyebeh
Elementary School in Minab, Hormozgan Province, Iran. He did so through
a scheme or course of conduct that effected the systemic deterioration
and removal of Department of Defense infrastructure that Congress had
mandated by law to limit collateral damage to civilians and non-
military objects during military operations. While doing so, Secretary
Hegseth also cultivated a war-making culture at the Department of
Defense which he boasts as being dismissive of ``stupid rules of
engagement'' with preference for ``maximum lethality, not tepid
legality.'' Such combination chilled and rendered ineffective
components of the Department of Defense responsible for preventing,
mitigating, and responding to civilian harm. By directing the
Department of Defense in a manner that foreseeably dismantled the
safeguards necessary to distinguish civilian objects from military
objectives, Secretary Hegseth thereby effected the murder of civilians
and abused the trust of the men and women under his command by
requiring them to conduct military operations within a targeting and
legal-review system that he had deliberately degraded. This undermined
the integrity and diplomacy of the United States and its Armed Forces.
He thus ignored and injured the interests of the Nation.
Secretary Hegseth engaged in this scheme or course of conduct
through the following means:
(1) Secretary Hegseth willfully disregarded and acted to
defeat the requirements of section 184 of title 10, United
States Code, by systematically dismantling civilian-protection
infrastructure, in that:
(A) Secretary Hegseth submitted a legislative
proposal to Congress on May 29, 2025, requesting a
repeal of section 184 of title 10, United States Code--
the statutory requirement for civilian protection
systems at the Department of Defense--even as Congress
had fully funded such systems for FY 2025 and FY 2026,
and after Congress did not enact the requested repeal,
Army officials nevertheless confirmed that such
civilian-harm mitigation activities had been halted.
(B) Secretary Hegseth intentionally stalled and
reversed implementation of the Civilian Harm Mitigation
and Response Action Plan (CHMR-AP) and rendered
ineffective the Civilian Protection Center of
Excellence (CP COE), despite it being congressionally
mandated by section 1082 of the James M. Inhofe
National Defense Authorization Act (Public Law 117-263)
and section 936 of the John S. McCain National Defense
Authorization Act (Public Law 115-232).
(C) Secretary Hegseth eliminated funding for the
Army's casualty-tracking database--the institutional
system for recording and verifying civilian harm
reports--so that, should civilians be harmed as a
result of United States military action, there would be
no functioning system within the Department of Defense
to review, verify, and report on such harm.
(D) Secretary Hegseth willfully refused to ensure
that DOD components received adequate resources to
satisfy CHMR requirements, including by removing more
than ninety percent of Civilian Harm Mitigation and
Response staff assigned to combatant commands.
(E) Secretary Hegseth failed, by the end of fiscal
year 2025, to satisfy any of the 11 objectives or
complete 133 actions mandated by Congress for the
prevention and mitigation of civilian harm during armed
conflict, thereby rendering every such component of the
Department of Defense's civilian harm prevention
apparatus partially or totally ineffective by the time
United States military combat operations against Iran
began in early 2026.
(2) Secretary Hegseth removed, without reason or cause, the
senior-most Judge Advocates General of the Army, Navy, and Air
Force--thereby undermining independent legal oversight of
combat operations and legal advice to commanders on the law of
armed conflict.
(3) Secretary Hegseth promulgated the 2026 National Defense
Strategy with all references to civilian protection omitted,
marking a deliberate and unprecedented departure from prior
defense policy that had recognized, in accordance with law,
civilian harm mitigation as a strategic priority.
(4) Secretary Hegseth, from the outset of his tenure,
instigated a departmental culture hostile to the law of armed
conflict and the protection of civilians through his public and
repeated denigration of rules of engagement as ``stupid,''
``politically correct,'' and ``overbearing,'' in that:
(A) On September 30, 2025, while addressing the
largest assembled gathering of United States generals
and admirals in American history, Secretary Hegseth
boasted that we, the United States military, ``don't
fight with stupid rules of engagement.''.
(B) Upon unlawfully renaming the Department of
Defense the Department of War, on September 5, 2025, he
poetically proclaimed: ``Maximum lethality, not tepid
legality. Violent effect, not politically correct.''.
(C) During his confirmation hearing on January 14,
2025, he told the Senate Armed Services Committee he
had ``thought very deeply about the balance between
legality and lethality, ensuring that the men and women
on the frontlines have the opportunity to destroy with
and close the enemy, and that lawyers aren't the ones
getting in the way.''.
(5) Secretary Hegseth undermined effective journalistic
oversight by expelling the traditional Pentagon press corps and
imposing credentialing rules that restricted journalists from
soliciting or publishing ``unapproved'' materials, thereby
weakening independent reporting on civilian harm and on matters
affecting the welfare and safety of United States service
members by journalists most familiar with the Department of
Defense.
These actions were not isolated administrative or rhetorical
choices. Taken together, they degraded the personnel, institutional
systems, independent legal review, and civilian-protection safeguards
upon which the Department of Defense relies to verify the current
status of proposed targets, distinguish civilian objects from military
objectives, reassess targets as circumstances change, and prevent or
mitigate civilian harm.
The foreseeable consequences of Secretary Hegseth's scheme
manifested in the United States strike on the Shajarah Tayyebeh
Elementary School, which killed and injured more than 200 civilians and
exposed systemic failures in the Department of Defense targeting
process. The events of that strike, and the reported events leading to
it, are as follows:
(1) On the morning of February 28, 2026, at approximately
9:45 a.m. local time, the United States, in partnership with
Israel, launched Operation Epic Fury, commencing the 2026 Iran
War. Within the first hour of the U.S.-Israeli offensive into
southern Iran, three BGM-109 Tomahawk cruise missiles fired
from United States Navy warships impacted the elementary school
between 10:23 and 10:45 a.m. local time.
(2) Because the war was commenced mid-morning on a
Saturday, the first day of the Iranian working week, students
were in attendance at the school. Despite an attempted
evacuation of the school, at the time of the first cruise
missile's impact, between 170 and 264 students were present in
the facility, most of whom were girls between the ages of seven
and twelve years.
(3) Whereas it is unclear how many casualties were
inflicted by the first impact, which caused a partial
destruction of the structure and the collapse of its roof, it
is reported that students were then sheltered in a prayer room
deeper in the facility, waiting for rescuers, when a second and
a third missile, in rapid succession, impacted the building.
(4) Reported death tolls from the strikes on the elementary
school indicate that at least 156 civilians were killed, with
some reports suggesting the civilian death toll surpassed 170.
Those killed include at least 120 schoolchildren, 26 teachers,
7 parents attempting to evacuate their children, a school bus
driver, a pharmacy technician from a nearby clinic, and the
six-month-old unborn child of one of the teachers also killed
in the attack. An estimated 95 other individuals were wounded.
Under United States military doctrine and the law of armed
conflict, which Secretary Hegseth is obligated to uphold, the
lawfulness of an attack does not depend solely upon whether civilians
were deliberately selected for the purpose of harming them. The
obligations of distinction, target verification, and feasible
precaution require military decision-makers to determine in good faith
that an object is a lawful military objective on the basis of
information reasonably available at the time. A failure to undertake
the verification and review required by those obligations may render an
attack unlawful, a failure directly caused by Secretary Hegseth's
dismantling of key infrastructure designed to prevent such errors. With
respect to the strike on the elementary school, those institutional
failures manifested in systemic noncompliance with Department of
Defense targeting doctrine and legal guidance.
The strike on the elementary school was not an isolated targeting
failure divorced from the conduct of the Secretary of Defense, nor can
Secretary Hegseth's conduct be dismissed as a single targeting error or
isolated failure in the fog of war. The elementary school was struck
after Secretary Hegseth sought to repeal congressionally mandated
civilian-protection requirements, dismantled the Department's civilian-
harm mitigation infrastructure, removed the senior-most Judge Advocates
General responsible for independent legal oversight, stripped civilian
protection from the National Defense Strategy, and publicly denigrated
legal restraints on military force as obstacles to ``maximum
lethality.'' He thereby weakened nearly every institutional safeguard
designed to minimize civilian casualties inflicted by the United States
military, and then presided over a targeting process in which a
functioning elementary school was struck three times, killing and
wounding more than 200 civilians, mostly children.
Such conduct reflects not merely a failure of judgment, but an
extraordinary abuse of the powers entrusted to the Secretary of Defense
and a profound disregard for the civilians his Department was obligated
to protect and the service members he was entrusted to lead.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth willfully and systemically
refused to comply with laws and directives mandated for the protection
of civilians during the commission of armed conflict, chilled and
rendered ineffective such components to prevent and mitigate harm to
civilians, and therefore, foreseeably effected the death and injury of
over 200 civilians, to the manifest injury of the United States.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to civilians, the lawful
conduct of United States military operations, the integrity and
credibility of the United States Armed Forces, and the Constitution if
allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
article v: extrajudicial killings
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct as Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his
constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--
especially with regard to the commission of war--has abused the powers
of the Department of Defense in that:
Using the powers of his office, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth
directed the Department of Defense in a manner that resulted in the
extrajudicial killings of at least 243 persons aboard seagoing vessels
alleged to be smuggling narcotics in the Caribbean Sea and the Eastern
Pacific Ocean, principally in international waters. He did so through a
scheme or course of conduct that chilled independent legal review
within the Department of Defense, constructed a purported legal basis
for the use of military force without constitutional or statutory
authorization, and displaced longstanding precedent and codified
maritime law-enforcement practices that are jurisdictionally assigned
to the Coast Guard and law enforcement agencies, by substituting in
such place the use of summary lethal force by Army, Navy, Air Force, or
Marine Corps elements. While doing so, Secretary Hegseth also oversaw
orders denying quarter and failing to provide rescue, including
secondary strikes against shipwrecked survivors, who were hors de
combat, and the abandonment of shipwrecked survivors at sea, thereby
endangering members of our Armed Forces in future military engagements
by encouraging adversaries to subject American service members to the
same treatment.
By subjecting persons merely suspected of criminal conduct to
lethal military force without judicial process, without congressional
authorization, and without establishing a lawful basis for treating
such persons or vessels as military targets, Secretary Hegseth
arrogated to himself and the Executive Branch the roles of judge, jury,
and executioner and asserted a unilateral power to determine who may
live and who may die. Such a power is foreign to the rule of law,
repugnant to the legal traditions and fundamental values of the United
States and the Western world, and contrary to United States law and
customary international law. This conduct undermined the integrity and
credibility of the United States and its Armed Forces, damaged the
diplomatic standing of the United States, and injured the interests of
the Nation.
Secretary Hegseth engaged in this scheme or course of conduct
through the following means:
(1) Secretary Hegseth authorized strikes, beginning on
September 2, 2025, without authorization from Congress pursuant
to Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 of the United States
Constitution, and in the absence of a declaration of war,
specific statutory authorization for the use of military force,
or a national emergency created by an attack upon the United
States, its territories or possessions, or its Armed Forces, as
provided in chapter 33 of title 50, United States Code.
(2) Secretary Hegseth ordered and oversaw the strike
campaign against seagoing vessels alleged to be smuggling
narcotics in international waters, comprising at least 69
separate attack events--46 in the Eastern Pacific Ocean, 21 in
the Caribbean Sea, and 2 in unspecified locations--which at
least struck 73 vessels and killed at least 243 individuals. In
doing so:
(A) Secretary Hegseth displaced the statutory
framework established by sections 70503 and 70504 of
title 46, United States Code, under which Congress
expressly treated maritime narcotics offenses,
including conduct occurring on the high seas, as
Federal crimes subject to apprehension, prosecution,
and trial in an appropriate United States district
court, and instead treated such offenses as predicates
for lethal military targeting.
(B) Secretary Hegseth disregarded the statutory
restrictions in sections 274 and 275 of title 10,
United States Code, governing direct participation by
members of the Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marine Corps
in civilian law enforcement activities, including
Federal narcotics enforcement, by employing lethal
military force against persons suspected of drug
trafficking absent any congressionally enacted
authorization for the use of military force or other
statutory authorization for such direct military
action.
(C) Secretary Hegseth disregarded the maritime law-
enforcement framework established by sections 102 and
522 of title 14, United States Code, as well as section
279 of title 10, United States Code, under which only
the Coast Guard is authorized to conduct interdiction,
search, seizure, and arrest, and he did so by directing
members of the Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marine Corps
to employ lethal military force in place of the law-
enforcement processes.
(3) Secretary Hegseth established targeting guidelines for
such strikes on August 5, 2025, by issuing an Execute Order
(EXORD) directing the use of United States military force
against persons alleged to be members or affiliates of certain
``Designated Terrorist Organizations'' (DTOs) as follows:
(A) Secretary Hegseth established guidelines that:
(i) used ``Designated Terrorist
Organizations'' as a targeting category,
notwithstanding that term is not a
congressionally created designation conferring
authority to use military force;
(ii) did not require positive
identification of any targeted person but
instead required only ``reasonable certainty''
that such person was a member or affiliate of a
DTO, a threshold lower than the ``near
certainty'' standard established for drone
strikes on suspected al-Qaeda militants during
the congressionally authorized Global War on
Terror; and
(iii) did not require the presence of
weapons or narcotics on targeted vessels
alleged to be smuggling narcotics in
association with a DTO.
(4) Secretary Hegseth, in the course of such strikes,
oversaw orders resulting in the denial of quarter to, and the
failure to provide timely rescue for, shipwrecked survivors of
initial strikes, including:
(A) On September 2, 2025, during the first strike
of the campaign, the United States Navy attacked a
seagoing vessel carrying 11 persons between the coast
of Venezuela and the nearby Caribbean nation of
Trinidad and Tobago. The strike destroyed and capsized
the vessel. Approximately 45 minutes later, while two
survivors clung to the wreckage, a secondary strike was
ordered, killing both survivors. In doing so, Secretary
Hegseth has endangered members of our Armed Forces in
future military engagements by encouraging adversaries
to subject American service members to the same
treatment; and
(B) On December 30, 2025, United States Southern
Command attacked three vessels approximately 400
nautical miles southwest of Ocos, Guatemala, in the
Eastern Pacific Ocean, killing 3 persons and leaving 8
others shipwrecked. Although the campaign had been
underway for approximately four months, no recovery
assets had been prepositioned to rescue survivors.
Rescue assets did not arrive until approximately 45
hours after the strikes, by which time all 8
shipwrecked survivors had died at sea. In doing so,
Secretary Hegseth has endangered members of our Armed
Forces in future military engagements by encouraging
adversaries to subject American service members to the
same treatment.
(5) Secretary Hegseth took actions to preempt, constrain,
and overcome independent legal objections within the Department
of Defense concerning the lawfulness of such strikes,
including:
(A) Secretary Hegseth removed the senior-most Judge
Advocates General of the Army, Navy, and Air Force.
without stating a reason or cause, thereby foreseeably
chilling the exercise of independent legal judgment by
judge advocates tasked with advising military
commanders on the lawfulness of combat operations, and
subsequently stating at a Pentagon Press conference on
February 25, 2025, that he did not want military
lawyers to serve as ``roadblocks to orders that are
given by a commander in chief.''.
(B) Secretary Hegseth employed an interagency group
of lawyers, comprising four career officials and four
political appointees from the Department of Defense,
the Office of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Central
Intelligence Agency, the White House, and the Office of
Legal Counsel, to develop a classified memorandum
purporting to establish a legal basis for such strikes
and to address anticipated objections to their
execution, falsely asserting the following:
(i) the United States is engaged in a non-
international armed conflict (NIAC) with 24
Latin American Designated Terrorist
Organizations (DTOs), thereby attempting to
displace the governing law-enforcement
framework, as established in paragraph (2), and
substitute an armed-conflict framework for the
conduct of military operations against such
organizations, despite the absence of
congressional authorization for such military
action, notwithstanding that--
(I) pursuant to Little v. Barreme
(1804), and Utility Air Regulatory
Group v. EPA (2014), an Executive
Branch legal memorandum cannot enlarge
authority conferred by Congress or
legalize conduct otherwise unauthorized
by statute;
(ii) the strikes do not constitute
``hostilities'' within the meaning of chapter
33 of title 50, United States Code, because
they do not place United States personnel in
danger, presumptively on the basis that such
vessels are incapable of self-defense--a
predicate that would likewise mean that any
military action conducted by drone, or any
airstrike against a target lacking air-defense
capabilities, could also not constitute
``hostilities''; and
(iii) the DTOs are engaged in armed
violence against the security forces of allied
nations, including Mexico, and such violence is
financed through cocaine trafficking, such that
the strikes may be characterized as attacks
against cocaine shipments and the deaths of
persons aboard targeted vessels as collateral
damage--a rationale inconsistent with the EXORD
targeting guidelines described in paragraph
(3), which did not require narcotics to be
present aboard a targeted vessel and instead
authorized targeting based on alleged DTO
membership or affiliation.
Secretary Hegseth abused the authority and trust vested in him as
Secretary of Defense not only by directing the unlawful use of lethal
military force, resulting in the summary execution of at least 243
persons in international waters, but also by using his office to compel
members of the Armed Forces to carry out such operations under false
legal authorities that he caused to be constructed and imposed upon the
chain of command. In denying quarter and refusing rescue, Secretary
Hegseth endangered members of the United States Armed Forces in future
military engagements by encouraging adversaries to subject American
service members to such treatment.
Secretary Hegseth further endangered United States law-enforcement
personnel by substituting lethal military targeting for the established
maritime law-enforcement practices of interdiction, search, seizure,
arrest, and prosecution. By demonstrating that vessels merely suspected
of narcotics trafficking may be destroyed and their occupants killed
rather than interdicted and arrested, Secretary Hegseth foreseeably
increased the likelihood that persons aboard such vessels will perceive
future encounters with United States authorities as threats to their
lives and respond with lethal force rather than surrender. In this
manner, his conduct not only endangered the persons unlawfully targeted
by the strike campaign but also made lawful enforcement of United
States narcotics laws at sea more dangerous for the Coast Guard and
other Federal personnel charged with carrying them out.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth has acted in a manner contrary to
his trust as Secretary of Defense and subversive of constitutional
government, to the great prejudice of the cause of law and justice, and
to the manifest injury of the people of the United States of America.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to civilians and the laws of
war, the integrity of the United States diplomacy, and the Constitution
if allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, profit
under the United States.
article vi: suppressing free speech
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct while Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States and to faithfully
discharge the duties of his office, abused the powers entrusted to him
by retaliating against a Member of Congress for constitutionally
protected speech and attempting to subject a member of a coordinate
branch of government to Executive Branch punishment for the exercise of
his legislative and oversight responsibilities, in that:
On November 18, 2025, Senator Mark Kelly, a retired United States
Navy Captain and National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
astronaut who flew 39 combat missions during the First Gulf War, and
who sits on the Senate Armed Services Committee and the Senate
Intelligence Committee, appeared in his official capacity as a Senator
in a video addressed to members of the United States Armed Forces,
stating: ``Our laws are clear. You can refuse illegal orders.''.
Despite such a statement being consistent with decisions in United
States v. Keenan (1969), and United States v. Calley (1973), Secretary
Hegseth weaponized the Department of Defense to retaliate against and
intimidate Senator Mark Kelly for such a statement. Secretary Hegseth
did so despite the fact that Senator Kelly is a sitting United States
Senator who cannot fulfill his role in representative government if he
fears Executive Branch reprisals for expressing his views. As the
Supreme Court held in Bond v. Floyd (1966), ``representative government
requires that legislators be given the widest latitude to express their
views on issues of policy.'' Members of Congress, moreover, enjoy
Speech or Debate immunity under Article I, Section 6, Clause 1 of the
United States Constitution, and Senator Kelly, as a retired service
member, is entitled to the full breadth of First Amendment protection.
Using the powers of his office, Secretary Hegseth retaliated
against and sought to intimidate United States Senator Mark Kelly for
his statement through a scheme or course of conduct intended to
interfere with Congress' constitutional authority to oversee the
Executive Branch, grossly expand Article II powers at the expense of
both the Legislative and Judicial Branches of government, and establish
a precedent that would chill the protected speech of millions of
retired United States service members and inflict irreparable harm upon
their First Amendment freedoms.
Secretary Hegseth engaged in this scheme or course of conduct
through the following means:
(1) On November 24, 2025, the Department of Defense,
through a social media post on X, threatened that Senator Mark
Kelly could be ``recall[ed] to active duty for court-martial
proceedings or administrative measures'' for his statement.
(2) On November 25, 2025, Secretary Hegseth directed the
Secretary of the Navy to review Senator Kelly.
(3) On January 5, 2026, Secretary Hegseth issued a
Secretarial Letter of Censure against Senator Kelly for:
(A) saying, ``You can refuse illegal orders'';
(B) saying he would ``ALWAYS defend the
Constitution'';
(C) questioning the legality of military operations
as a member of the Senate Armed Services and
Intelligence Committees;
(D) criticizing military leadership (Hegseth) for
surrounding themselves (himself) with ``yes men''; and
(E) allegedly accusing Secretary Hegseth of war
crimes.
(4) In the Letter of Censure, Secretary Hegseth also
threatened Senator Kelly with ``criminal prosecution or further
administrative action,'' including the reduction of Senator
Kelly's retired military grade should the Senator continue to
question the legality of military operations or criticize
Secretary Hegseth.
(5) In response to a January 12, 2026, complaint filed by
Senator Mark Kelly against Secretary Hegseth for retaliating
against and intimidating the Senator for his First Amendment-
protected speech, Secretary Hegseth filed a memorandum of
opposition to Senator Kelly's motion for a preliminary
injunction, egregiously asserting:
(A) Senator Kelly, as a retired naval officer, has
diminished First Amendment protections;
(B) Department of Defense actions against Senator
Kelly's constitutional rights, due to his statements
relating to military affairs, and his being a retired
naval officer, constitute nonjusticiable military
personnel decisions;
(C) Secretary Hegseth's opinions supersede the
court's jurisdiction to determine whether the
government could censure, threaten, and financially
punish Senator Kelly because of his speech; and
(D) Senator Kelly is required to exhaust military
administrative remedies before seeking relief in an
Article III court, thereby seeking to place the
adjudication of Senator Kelly's constitutional rights
within military processes controlled by the Executive
Branch.
Thus, in addition to abusing the powers of the office of Secretary
of Defense for politically motivated reprisal against Senator Kelly for
the Senator's criticism of conduct implicating potential war crimes,
Secretary Hegseth grossly violated, or sought to violate, the
separation of powers by attempting to subordinate both the Legislative
and Judicial Branches, in matters concerning constitutional rights, to
the authority of the Department of Defense. In the same effort,
Secretary Hegseth sought, without precedent, to extend to retired
service members the diminished First Amendment protections applicable
to active-duty service members under Parker v. Levy (1974), including
retired service members serving in Congress and exercising
constitutional oversight over the military. He further asserted, in
substance, that the military, rather than Article III courts, possesses
supremacy to determine the constitutional rights of civilians and to
adjudicate whether its own actions conform to the Constitution and laws
of the United States, at minimum with respect to the speech of retired
service members, despite such position being in flagrant conflict with
Marbury v. Madison (1803), which holds that ``it is emphatically the
province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is,''
not the military.
The result of such effort, had Secretary Hegseth been successful,
would have subjected the speech and congressional oversight activities
of nearly twenty percent of the current Congress--and whatever
proportion of future Congresses may consist of retired service
members--as well as the speech of millions of other retired service
members, to the will and discretion of the Department of Defense,
without any immediate avenue of recourse outside the Department to
vindicate their constitutional rights. Such a result would constitute
one of the most extraordinary expansions of Executive Branch power in
the history of the United States.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of the
Department of Defense by retaliating against and attempting to
intimidate a sitting United States Senator through threats of
punishment for speech protected by the First Amendment to the United
States Constitution, in an effort to deter that Senator from fulfilling
his constitutional role in overseeing the Executive Branch. In doing
so, Secretary Hegseth weaponized the Department of Defense to chill a
core function of the Legislative Branch, encroach upon the
constitutional role of the Judicial Branch by seeking to insulate such
retaliation from meaningful judicial review, and, through the precedent
he sought to establish, place the First Amendment rights of millions of
United States veterans at risk of irreparable harm.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution and the
separation of powers if allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a
manner grossly incompatible with his duties, the rule of law, and the
constitutional liberties entrusted to his protection. Peter Brian
Hegseth thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
article vii: kidnapping of a sovereign foreign leader
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In. his conduct of the office of
Secretary of Defense--and in violation of his constitutional oath to
faithfully execute the office of Secretary of Defense and, to the best
of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the
United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty to take care
that the laws be faithfully executed--especially during the commission
of war--Peter Brian Hegseth has abused the powers of the Department of
Defense, in that:
Using the powers of his office, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth
directed the Department of Defense to carry out an unprecedented
military operation--code-named ABSOLUTE RESOLVE--to capture and kidnap
President Nicolas Maduro, the leader of the Bolivarian Republic of
Venezuela, and his wife, Cilia Flores, from Venezuela--an act of war
against a sovereign country executed under the guise of narcotics law
enforcement, though in actuality intended to assert U.S. control over
Venezuela's oil reserves. In doing so, he gambled the lives of Army,
Navy, Air Force, and Marine Corps personnel in order to facilitate the
illegal taking of national oil. To wit, immediately following such
attack, Secretary Hegseth appeared alongside President Donald J. Trump,
during which the President announced in reference to Venezuela, ``We're
going to run the country until such time as we can do a safe, proper,
and judicious transition. So, we don't want to be involved with, uh,
having somebody else get in. And we have the same situation that we had
. . . we're going to run it, essentially''; and ``We're going to have
our very large United States oil companies, the biggest anywhere in the
world, go in . . . and start making money . . . and we are ready to
stage a second and much larger attack if we need to do so,'' thus,
revealing the motives behind the forcible removal of President Maduro,
which extended far. beyond the narcotics-law-enforcement rationale on
which the operation was falsely predicated.
On January 3, 2026, Secretary Hegseth directed United States Armed
Forces into hostilities in and around Caracas, Venezuela, employing
more than 200 United States special operations personnel on the ground
and more than 150 aircraft and drones, including fighter aircraft,
bombers, armed helicopters, and electronic warfare aircraft, supported
by a substantial naval force that included the Iwo Jima Amphibious
Ready Group and the Gerald R. Ford Carrier Strike Group, which together
penetrated Venezuelan territory, suppressed and destroyed Venezuelan
air defenses, struck multiple targets in the Caracas area, inserted an
armed ground force into Caracas to seize Maduro, successfully kidnapped
Maduro, killed at least 83 people, including several civilians, and
caused 7 American casualties. In doing so:
(1) Secretary Hegseth executed unlawful orders effecting
the removal of the President of a sovereign nation, placed
boots on the ground, conducted preparatory bombardments,
inflicted substantial casualties, and subsequently caused
regime change, each of which constitutes acts of war;
(2) Secretary Hegseth executed unlawful orders violating
Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 of the United States
Constitution by--
(i) ordering United States Armed Forces to commit
an act of war against Venezuela without a declaration
of war by Congress against such nation; and
(ii) making rules concerning Captures on Land, a
power specifically vested in Congress, where Congress
had made no rules authorizing or otherwise applicable
to such operation; and
(3) Secretary Hegseth executed unlawful orders in
contravention of Section 2(c) of the War Powers Resolution of
1973, section 1541(c) of title 50; United States Code, by
entering United States Armed Forces into hostilities in
Venezuela on January 3, 2026, without a declaration of war, a
specific statutory authorization, or a national emergency
created by attack upon the United States, its territories or
possessions, or its Armed Forces.
Through these actions, Secretary Hegseth knowingly directed United
States Armed Forces into hostilities against a sovereign foreign nation
without clear constitutional or specific statutory authority, employing
military force of a nature and magnitude rising to the level of
constitutional war. In doing so; Secretary Hegseth usurped Congress's
constitutional authority over war and transformed the Department of
Defense into an instrument for objectives extending far beyond the
apprehension of Nicolas Maduro for purposes of narcotics law
enforcement, including regime change and the acquisition of foreign
oil.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of the
Department of Defense, violated the laws and treaty obligations of the
United States, and subordinated the constitutional allocation of war
powers to Executive objectives neither authorized nor approved by
Congress.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution and the
wellbeing of United States military personnel if allowed to remain in
office, and has acted in a manner grossly incompatible with his duties
and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth thus warrants impeachment and
trial, removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any
office of honor, trust, or profit under the United States.
article viii: unlawful war in yemen
The Constitution provides that the House of Representatives ``shall
have the sole Power of Impeachment'' and that civil officers of the
United States, including the Secretary of Defense, ``shall be removed
from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or
other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.'' In his conduct while Secretary of
Defense, Peter Brian Hegseth, in violation of his oath to support and
defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his
constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--
especially with regard to the commission of war--has abused the powers
of the Department of Defense in that:
Using the powers of his office, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth
directed the Department of Defense in a manner leading to the deaths of
an estimated 224 civilians, as well as approximately 500 to 600 Houthi
fighters, through the initiation and direction of Operation Rough
Rider. The operation comprised more than 1,100 strikes against targets
in Yemen over approximately 52 days. In less than eight weeks, there
were nearly as many civilian deaths in Yemen as United States military
actions had caused in that country during the preceding twenty-three
years. Secretary Hegseth initiated and directed these hostilities in
the absence of any of the predicates required in section 2(c) of the
War Powers Resolution of 1973 for the President to introduce United
States Armed Forces into hostilities. Moreover, Secretary Hegseth
acknowledged the absence of any imminent threat to the United States,
further undermining any assertion of Article II authority to initiate
such hostilities without congressional authorization.
Secretary Hegseth initiated and directed Operation Rough Rider
without congressional authority pursuant to Article I, Section 8,
Clause 11 of the United States Constitution, or statutory
authorization, in that:
(1) Secretary Hegseth executed unlawful orders in
contravention of Section 2(c) of the War Powers Resolution of
1973, section 1541(c) of title 50, United States Code, by
entering and sustaining United States Navy and Air Force
personnel into hostilities in Yemen between March 15 and May 6,
2025, without a declaration of war, a specific statutory
authorization, or a national emergency created by attack upon
the United States, its territories or possessions, or its Armed
Forces.
(2) Secretary Hegseth executed unlawful orders in
contravention of section 4(a) of the War Powers Resolution of
1973, section 1543(a) of title 50, United States Code, by
continuing to direct United States Armed Forces into
hostilities in Yemen after March 17, 2025, despite the
President of the United States having failed to notify Congress
of such hostilities within 48 hours of their commencement, as
required by section 4(a), and notwithstanding that the
President did not transmit such a report to Congress until
March 28, 2025, thereby further undermining any possible
Article II authority for the continued hostilities, especially
during such 13-day period.
(3) Outside of the requirements to engage in hostilities
pursuant to the War Powers Resolution of 1973, Secretary
Hegseth directed Operation Rough Rider in the absence of any
imminent threat requiring military action without prior
congressional authorization, as evidenced by a leaked Signal
chat involving Secretary Hegseth, concerning the potential
execution of Operation Rough Rider, in which:
(A) Several senior United States government
officials, including Secretary Hegseth, each possessing
unfettered access to military and intelligence
information, advised there was no immediate need to
enter United States Armed Forces into hostilities in
Yemen, thereby asserting there was no imminent threat
to the United States, its possessions or territories,
or its Armed Forces, as indicated through the following
communications:
(i) Vice President JD Vance stating,
``there is a strong argument for delaying
[Operation Rough Rider] a month'';
(ii) then-Acting Chief of Staff to the
National Security Advisor Joe Kent stating,
``There is nothing time sensitive driving this
timeline. We'll have the exact same options in
a month'';
(iii) Central Intelligence Agency Director
John Ratcliffe stating, ``a delay would not
negatively impact us and additional time would
be used to identify better starting points for
coverage on Houthi leadership'';
(iv) addressing the timing of Operation
Rough Rider, Secretary Hegseth stated, ``we can
easily pause''; and
(v) addressing the Vice President's
concerns regarding Operation Rough Rider's
immediate commencement, Secretary Hegseth
stated, ``VP: I understand your concerns . . .
2 immediate risks on waiting: (1) this leaks
and we look indecisive; (2) Israel takes action
first--or Gaza cease fire falls apart--and we
don't get to start this on our own terms . . .
This is not about the Houthis [it's about]
[r]eestablish[ing] deterrence, which Biden
cratered.''.
Thus, Secretary Hegseth knew there was no imminent threat to the
United States, its territories or possessions, or its Armed Forces, as,
had such a threat existed, there would have been no basis for him to
state that ``we can easily pause.'' Moreover, the only ``immediate
risks'' identified by Secretary Hegseth concerned media optics and
Israeli affairs, rather than the direct affairs of the United States of
America, the nation to which his oath is sworn.
In all of this, Secretary Hegseth abused the powers entrusted to
him as Secretary of Defense by subordinating the constitutional limits
on the use of military force and the laws governing the conduct of
hostilities to his own policy objectives, notwithstanding his knowledge
that no imminent threat to the United States existed, and demonstrated
a profound disregard for civilian life, the rule of law, the
constitutional authority of Congress, and his duty to ensure the lawful
conduct of the United States Armed Forces.
Wherefore, Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth, by such conduct, has
demonstrated that he will remain a threat to civilians, the lawful
conduct of United States military operations, the integrity and
credibility of the United States Armed Forces, and the Constitution if
allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly
incompatible with his duties and the rule of law. Peter Brian Hegseth
thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and
disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or
profit under the United States.
<all>